Would Ben Johnson Consider Starting Tyson Bagent Over Caleb Williams?
After an underwhelming opening night performance by rookie quarterback Caleb Williams, questions are swirling around the Chicago Bears. Despite solid numbers, Williams struggled with accuracy and decision-making, leading some to wonder if backup Tyson Bagent might see playing time sooner than expected. Former quarterback Tim Jenkins has fueled this speculation, suggesting that Bagent possesses the qualities that head coach Ben Johnson values.
The Bagent Factor: A Good Fit for Johnson's System?
Jenkins, familiar with both quarterbacks, revealed on Hoge & Jahns that Bagent believes he is a starter and chose to re-sign with the Bears, possibly anticipating an opportunity under Johnson. Bagent is known as a pocket passer who excels at pre-snap reads and accurate throws, although he lacks the arm strength and athleticism of Williams. Despite Williams's talent, the mental aspect of the game might favor Bagent, who is known for his tireless work ethic and dedication to film study.
Johnson's Perspective: Talent vs. System
Johnson had success in Detroit with Jared Goff, a quarterback who may not have possessed elite talent but effectively ran the offensive system. If Williams fails to improve his consistency and decision-making, Johnson might be willing to sacrifice some talent in favor of a quarterback who can execute the offense as intended. The next few weeks will be crucial for Williams to demonstrate progress; otherwise, Johnson could consider turning to Bagent.
Immediate Speculation and High Standards
Following the Bears' opening night loss, speculation arose regarding Williams's ability to overcome his tendencies to hold the ball too long and struggle with accuracy. The question of whether Johnson would consider starting Bagent quickly surfaced. While a change isn't expected imminently, one source indicated that Johnson won't tolerate prolonged struggles. "Nobody is panicking in the building, but Ben isn’t going to watch him miss big plays for 10 weeks."
Consistency Over Raw Talent?
Although Bagent lacks the raw talent of Williams, he possesses size, accuracy, and a strong command of the line of scrimmage. Johnson prioritizes a quarterback he can trust to execute the offense effectively. He may be willing to trade some raw talent for the consistency that Bagent could provide, making the quarterback situation in Chicago one to watch closely in the coming weeks.