Manorbier School Faces Closure Years After Devastating Fire
Pupils of Manorbier VC School in Pembrokeshire, who have been learning in a village hall since a fire destroyed their school in October 2022, now face the possibility of permanent closure. Parents are accusing Pembrokeshire council of failing the community and breaking promises to rebuild the school.
The Fire and its Aftermath
The fire, which broke out in the roof space of Manorbier VC School in October 2022, forced the school to relocate its 28 pupils to nearby Jameston Village Hall. The original school building would have celebrated its 150th anniversary in January 2023. Despite the efforts of staff, parents argue that the village hall is not a suitable long-term learning environment.
Community Outcry and Council Response
More than 1,000 people have signed a petition urging the council to rebuild the school, accusing them of breaking promises. Parents like Becky and Charlotte express anger and disappointment at the lack of support from the council. Becky, a former pupil and mother of a Year 2 student, stated that the community feels let down. Charlotte claimed that no one from the council helped move books after the fire.
Council's Rationale and Alternatives
In May, Pembrokeshire council cited a high level of surplus places (77.9%) and a falling demographic as reasons for considering closure. The estimated cost to rebuild the school is approximately £2.6 million. The council cabinet stated that all views will be taken into consideration during the consultation process. The consultation includes discussions with St David's Diocese on closing Manorbier and Ysgol Clydau. However the Diocese had always expected the school to be reinstated, until the consultation was announced.
Political Involvement and Future Prospects
Sam Kurtz, Conservative Senedd member for Carmarthen West and South Pembrokeshire, has accused the council of breaking promises to rebuild the school. He suggests the fire is being used as an excuse for closure. The consultation is in its final stages, and the future of Manorbier VC School remains uncertain.
Similar Situations: St Martins School Fire
In a separate incident, St Martins School near Oswestry experienced a fire, causing damage to the art center and dining room. Head teacher Alison Pope highlighted the community's response, with locals and teaching staff rallying to provide support. The local community center and supermarket, Stan's Superstore, also offered assistance.
Petitions and Community Action
An e-petition on behalf of Manorbier, has gained over 1,000 signatures. A petition with over 500 signatures triggers a debate at a full council meeting. The petition emphasizes the school's 152-year history and the detrimental impact closure would have on the community. A separate petition to save Ysgol Clydau has also been launched.
