New York Democratic Party in Turmoil: Jacobs' Refusal to Endorse Mamdani Sparks Division
The New York Democratic Party is facing a significant ideological rift as State Democratic Chairman Jay Jacobs refuses to endorse socialist Zohran Mamdani's mayoral bid. This decision has triggered calls for Jacobs' resignation from progressive members, while moderates are applauding his stance. The controversy highlights deep divisions within the party regarding its overall direction.
Reactions to Jacobs' Decision
Moderate figures such as incumbent Mayor Eric Adams and former Governor Andrew Cuomo have publicly praised Jacobs for his "common sense" approach in not supporting Mamdani. However, this support is overshadowed by the progressive backlash against Jacobs, especially after Gov. Kathy Hochul's endorsement of Mamdani. The situation underscores a break with the party's nominee in New York City.
State Senator Michael Gianaris, a progressive voice, expressed his disapproval on X, stating, "Disgraceful. The Chair of the Democratic Party refusing to support the candidate clearly selected by the voters of the Democratic Party." He questioned Jacobs' role if he won't fulfill the basic responsibility of supporting the party's chosen candidate. State Senator Kristen Gonzalez echoed similar sentiments, directly calling for Jay Jacobs' resignation.
Roots of the Conflict
Many Democrats have been critical of Jacobs' leadership, even prior to this incident. His non-endorsement of Mamdani, accompanied by a statement criticizing the Democratic Socialists of America platform, has intensified existing tensions. Some believe his "mild-mannered approach" failed to energize voters and contributed to the party's performance in the 2022 midterm elections.
While Mamdani did not directly call for Jacobs' resignation during a Manhattan event with Senate Majority Leader Andrea Stewart-Cousins, he did question Jacobs' reasoning that he would alienate moderates. He highlighted his primary win and gains among voters who previously supported President Trump, suggesting that Jacobs is "out of step with the future" of the party and the city.
Potential Consequences and Broader Implications
The impact of Jacobs' stance on the flow of state Democratic Party resources into the mayoral race remains uncertain. Democratic consultant Chris Sosa argues that this divisive behavior is "actively undermining party unity and spitting in the face of Gov. Hochul." He believes this internal conflict is an unwelcome distraction for both Hochul and Mamdani.
While Mamdani has energized young voters, he has faced challenges in securing endorsements from prominent New York Democrats, such as House Minority Leader Hakeem Jeffries and Senate Minority Leader Chuck Schumer. However, he has gained the backing of progressives like Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez and Bernie Sanders. Gov. Hochul's recent endorsement, along with that of Assembly Speaker Carl Heastie, signals a potential shift, possibly aimed at strengthening her credibility among progressives ahead of a potential primary challenge.
Adams and Cuomo Weigh In
Eric Adams, who is trailing Mamdani significantly in the polls, criticized the leftward shift of the party and condemned the "troubling" support for Mamdani. He argued that Mamdani's "reckless rhetoric and dangerous policies threaten to divide our communities." Adams specifically mentioned Mamdani's stance on antisemitism and his "radical economic vision" as being "out of step with mainstream Democrats." He lauded Jacobs' "independence" and supported his continued leadership.
Andrew Cuomo stated that he couldn't recall a time when the Democratic chair contradicted the governor on endorsing a mayoral candidate. He claimed that Mamdani is not a Democrat but a socialist, further emphasizing the ideological divide. Democratic political operative Ken Frydman criticized Jacobs for "giving away the left flank" and failing in his role to register voters. He suggested Jacobs should "fall on the sword or be fired."
One party source indicated broader dissatisfaction with Jacobs' leadership, suggesting he lacks the focus needed to win. The internal conflict highlights the significant challenges facing the New York Democratic Party as it navigates a deep ideological chasm.
