Conservative Voices Criticize CBS News Host's Question Following Charlie Kirk's Assassination
Nate Burleson, co-host of "CBS Mornings," is facing backlash after questioning former House Speaker Kevin McCarthy (R-Calif.) about whether the Republican party should "reflect" on its rhetoric in light of the assassination of Turning Point USA founder Charlie Kirk. Critics argue that Burleson's question inappropriately politicized a tragic event.
Reactions to Burleson's Question
The question was posed following the death of Charlie Kirk, who was shot in the neck while speaking at Utah Valley University. The incident has sparked widespread reactions, with some critics focusing on Kirk's rhetoric and its potential impact. Award-winning broadcaster Tim Brando, formerly of CBS Sports, expressed his disapproval of Burleson's comments, stating that such rhetoric "would never have been tolerated" during his time at the network.
"I have nothing but positive things to say about my experiences there. The level of professionalism and decorum was its calling card. Walking thru the Broadcast Center to Studio 43 was an honor. This kind of rhetoric would never have been tolerated," - Tim Brando on X.
Fox News announced a primetime special, ‘Charlie Kirk: An American Original,’ to honor the conservative leader.
Burleson's Question and McCarthy's Response
Burleson's question to McCarthy focused on the potential role of political leaders' rhetoric in contributing to political violence. He asked, "Speaking of this tragedy, is this a moment for your party to reflect on political violence? Is it a moment for us to think about the responsibility of our political leaders and their voices and what it does to the masses as they get lost in misinformation or disinformation that turns in, and spills into, political violence?" Co-host Gayle King suggested that "both parties" should reflect. McCarthy responded by suggesting rising political violence is an issue for the entire nation to address.
Further Criticism and Responses
Conservative commentator Steve Guest labeled Burleson's remarks as "unhinged." Former NFL player and congressional candidate Jay Feely accused Burleson of being "highly offensive," suggesting that calling one side "racist Nazis" encourages violence. Townhall columnist Dustin Grage said Burleson needs to "read the room," while Meghan McCain criticized the CBS host, expressing hope that Bari Weiss, reportedly joining CBS News in a leadership role, can improve the network.
"This was highly offensive Nate Burleson. Charlie Kirk was assassinated in front of his family and you ask if Republicans need to tone down their rhetoric? When you call one side racist Nazis that are a threat to democracy you encourage this Violence," - Jay Feely.
NewsBusters managing editor Curtis Houck stated Burleson got "WAY, WAY, WAY out over his skis." Political pundit Stephen L. Miller expressed skepticism about any potential change within the network following the incident. Conservative radio host Erick Erickson suggested Burleson should be on the layoff list. NewsBusters associate editor Nicholas Fondacaro called it "absolutely ghoulish behavior," and OutKick columnist Bobby Burack labeled the CBS News host "clueless."
CBS News' Response
As of the report, CBS News and Paramount have not responded to requests for comment.
Former Speaker McCarthy Reflects on the Death of Charlie Kirk
Former House Speaker Kevin McCarthy reflected on the death of Charlie Kirk and his relationship with the conservative activist on September 12, 2025.
