Fetterman Breaks with Democrats, Says Trump "Not an Autocrat"
In a recent CNN interview, U.S. Senator John Fetterman of Pennsylvania once again diverged from his Democratic colleagues, asserting that Donald Trump is "not an autocrat." Fetterman's comments highlight a continuing pattern of independent thinking and a willingness to challenge prevailing narratives within his party.
Fetterman's Stance on Trump and the Democratic Party
Speaking to Manu Raju on CNN's "Inside Politics Sunday," Fetterman stated, "This is not an autocrat. This is a product of a democratic election. We lost, and the American people put us in the minority. That’s democracy." He suggested that overly divisive language and progressive policies contributed to the Democratic Party's losses in the 2024 presidential election and subsequent control of the House and Senate by Republicans.
Fetterman emphasized that the Democratic Party has "really lost our connection with American voters." The first-term senator, who faces reelection in 2028, has increasingly positioned himself as a voice for moderate and working-class voters.
Criticism of Government Shutdown and Immigration Policies
Beyond his comments on Trump, Fetterman expressed his disapproval of potential government shutdowns, highlighting their negative impact on constituents. He also criticized the administration's approach to targeting hard-working immigrants without criminal records. This is another instance where he set himself apart from other Democratic leaders.
Diverging Views on National Guard Deployment
Fetterman also differed from many Democrats in his assessment of Trump's deployment of the National Guard in Washington, D.C., and potential use in other cities. Drawing from his experience as the former mayor of Braddock, Pennsylvania, Fetterman indicated that he would have welcomed such support during his tenure. He stated, "If Trump is calling for something X, Y, and Z, then that doesn’t mean we have to necessarily oppose that."
A History of Breaking with Party Lines
Fetterman's recent statements are part of a larger pattern of breaking with Democratic orthodoxy. He has been a vocal supporter of Israel, criticized protests against U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement raids as "anarchy," and voted to confirm a significant number of Trump's cabinet picks. In January, he visited then-President-elect Trump at Mar-a-Lago and has cultivated a friendship with conservative Pennsylvania Senator Dave McCormick.
Past Criticisms and Mental Health
Earlier this year, Fetterman faced criticism following a New York Magazine article that raised concerns about his mental health and ability to perform his duties. Fetterman, who received inpatient treatment for depression in 2023, dismissed the article as a "hit piece" containing false allegations. The Inquirer, along with other outlets, also reported on these concerns.
